Toyota Highlander vs Honda Pilot

On the federal record, the 2011 Toyota Highlander takes it: 69/100 against 5/100. Best-scoring model year of each, judged only on complaints and recalls filed with the United States safety regulator.

2011 Toyota Highlander

69/100
CAUTION
  • 186 owner complaints on record
  • 12.4 complaints per year on the road
  • 5 recall campaigns, 1 severe

2016 Honda Pilot

5/100
AVOID
  • 1,681 owner complaints on record
  • 168.1 complaints per year on the road
  • 8 recall campaigns, 5 severe

Scores compare the best data-year of each nameplate. Click through for every model year, owner narratives and running costs.

More head-to-heads

Tesla Model 3 vs Toyota CamryToyota Camry wins on data, 90/100Nissan Altima vs Toyota CamryToyota Camry wins on data, 90/100Nissan Rogue vs Toyota RAV4Toyota RAV4 wins on data, 61/100Subaru Outback vs Toyota RAV4Toyota RAV4 wins on data, 61/100Hyundai Elantra vs Toyota CorollaToyota Corolla wins on data, 62/100Kia Telluride vs Toyota HighlanderToyota Highlander wins on data, 69/100Ford Escape vs Toyota RAV4Toyota RAV4 wins on data, 61/100Chevrolet Equinox vs Honda CR-VChevrolet Equinox wins on data, 57/100Hyundai Tucson vs Kia SportageKia Sportage wins on data, 81/100Subaru Forester vs Honda CR-VSubaru Forester wins on data, 61/100Hyundai Sonata vs Hyundai Elantra TouringHyundai Elantra Touring wins on data, 39/100